Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 78-79: Q8: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-5 Newtons Laws of Motion P 78-79: Q8 Solution: A particle is observed from two frames S_1 and S_2 . Frame S_2…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often incorrectly assume that if one frame is inertial, the other must also be inertial or that pseudo-forces are global properties. Remember that pseudo-force is strictly frame-dependent: if $S_2$ has relative acceleration $a$ with respect to $S_1$, then $F_2 = -ma$ is non-zero, making the scenario where $F_1 \neq 0$ (implying $S_1$ is non-inertial) but $F_2 = 0$ (implying $S_2$ is inertial) physically impossible given their relative motion.

A particle is observed from two frames S1S_1 and S2S_2. Frame S2S_2 moves with respect to S1S_1 with an acceleration aa. Let F1F_1 and F2F_2 be the pseudo forces on the particle when seen from S1S_1 and S2S_2, respectively. Which of the following is not possible?

Multiple Choice Options

  • A F1=0,F2≠0F_1 = 0, F_2 \neq 0
  • B F1≠0,F2=0F_1 \neq 0, F_2 = 0
  • C F1≠0,F2≠0F_1 \neq 0, F_2 \neq 0
  • D F1=0,F2=0F_1 = 0, F_2 = 0

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

The correct option is **(b) F1≠0, F2=0F_1\neq0,\ F_2=0**. ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Pseudo-Force in Different Frames** If S2S_2 accelerates relative to S1S_1 with acceleration aa, the pseudo-force in S2S_2 is
F⃗2=−ma⃗\vec F_2=-m\vec a
while S1S_1 can be inertial, giving F1=0F_1=0. 2. **Possible Values** The two frames' pseudo-forces differ according to their accelerations. The stated combination that cannot occur is F1≠0F_1\neq0 with F2=0F_2=0, because the frames have nonzero relative acceleration. 3. **Conclusion** Hence, **option (b)** is not possible.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation