Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 77-78: Q14: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-5 Newtons Laws of Motion P 77-78: Q14 Solution: A free ^ 238 U nucleus kept in a train emits an alpha particle. …

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often incorrectly add the train's velocity $v$ to the separation distance, assuming the moving frame shifts the position of one particle relative to the other. However, since both the alpha particle and the recoiling nucleus acquire the same translational velocity $v$, their relative velocity and thus their separation $x$ remain invariant in any inertial frame.

A free 238U^{238}\text{U} nucleus kept in a train emits an alpha particle. When the train is stationary, a nucleus decays and a passenger measures that the separation between the alpha particle and the recoiling nucleus becomes xx at time tt after the decay. If the decay takes place while the train is moving at a uniform velocity vv, the distance between the alpha particle and the recoiling nucleus at a time tt after the decay, as measured by the passenger, is

Multiple Choice Options

  • A x+vtx + vt
  • B x−vtx - vt
  • C xx
  • D depends on the direction of the train

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

The correct option is **(c) xx.** ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Uniform Translation** The moving train is an inertial frame because it moves with uniform velocity relative to the stationary train. 2. **Relative Separation** The alpha particle and recoiling nucleus both acquire the same additional velocity vv from the train's motion. Their relative velocity is therefore unchanged.
v⃗α/N=v⃗α−v⃗N\vec v_{\alpha/N}=\vec v_\alpha-\vec v_N
3. **Distance After Time tt** Since their relative motion is unchanged, the separation after time tt remains exactly the same as in the stationary train.
x′=xx'=x
4. **Conclusion** The passenger measures **xx**, so **option (c)** is correct.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation