Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 76-77: Q16: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-5 Newtons Laws of Motion P 76-77: Q16 Solution: When a train starts, the head of a standing passenger seems to…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often incorrectly assume the head physically accelerates backward in the ground frame; clarify that in an inertial ground frame, the head simply retains its initial velocity (or remains at rest) due to inertia while the train accelerates forward, making the backward motion purely relative.

When a train starts, the head of a standing passenger seems to be pushed backward. Analyse the situation from the ground frame. Does it really go backward? Coming back to the train frame, how do you explain the backward movement of the head on the basis of Newton's laws?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** **From the ground frame the head does not really move backward; in the train frame it appears to move backward because of inertia.** ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Ground Frame** When the train starts accelerating forward, the passenger's feet are pushed forward by the train through friction, but the head initially tends to retain its previous state of motion.
a⃗head≈0\vec a_{\text{head}}\approx0
Thus, relative to the ground, the head does not move backward; it may remain approximately at rest while the train moves forward beneath it. 2. **Relative Motion** The train moves forward while the head initially retains its velocity. Therefore, relative to the accelerating train, the head appears to move backward.
a⃗relative=a⃗head−a⃗train≈−a⃗train\vec a_{\text{relative}}=\vec a_{\text{head}}-\vec a_{\text{train}}\approx-\vec a_{\text{train}}
3. **Train Frame** The train frame is non-inertial. A backward pseudo-force acts on the passenger in this frame:
Fpseudo=−maF_{\text{pseudo}}=-ma
4. **Conclusion** The head **does not actually accelerate backward in the ground frame**. Its backward movement is a relative-motion effect, explained in the train frame by **inertia and the pseudo-force**.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation