Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 76-77: Q17: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-5 Newtons Laws of Motion P 76-77: Q17 Solution: A plumb bob is hung from the ceiling of a train compartment. If …

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students may assume that the angle $ heta= an^{-1}(a/g)$ of a plumb bob uniquely signals horizontal acceleration $a$, but the same angle can arise from a uniformly moving train on an incline of angle $ an^{-1}(a/g)$; the bob only reflects the direction of the total effective acceleration, not its origin.

A plumb bob is hung from the ceiling of a train compartment. If the train moves with an acceleration aa along a straight horizontal track, the string supporting the bob makes an angle tan⁡−1(a/g)\tan^{-1}(a/g) with the normal to the ceiling. Suppose the train moves on an inclined straight track with uniform velocity. If the angle of incline is tan⁡−1(a/g)\tan^{-1}(a/g), the string again makes the same angle with the normal to the ceiling. Can a person sitting inside the compartment tell by looking at the plumb line whether the train is accelerating on a horizontal straight track or moving on an incline? If yes, how? If not, then suggest a method to do so.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** **No. Looking only at the plumb line is insufficient; an additional dynamical experiment is needed.** ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Same Plumb-Line Direction** In both situations, the plumb line makes the same angle with the normal to the ceiling. For horizontal acceleration aa,
tan⁡θ=ag\tan\theta=\frac{a}{g}
A uniformly moving inclined train can produce the same apparent direction because of the component of gravity along the incline. 2. **Why the Plumb Line Is Insufficient** A single observation of the string gives only the direction of the effective acceleration. It does not reveal whether that direction results from actual train acceleration or from the train's orientation relative to gravity. 3. **Dynamical Test** Perform an experiment involving a body moving relative to the compartment, such as measuring its acceleration along the track. The uniformly moving inclined train is an inertial frame (neglecting Earth's rotation), whereas the accelerating horizontal train is non-inertial. 4. **Conclusion** **The plumb line alone cannot distinguish the two cases.** A dynamical experiment inside the compartment can distinguish them by testing whether the compartment frame is inertial.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation