Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 225: Q1: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-11 Gravitation P 225: Q1 Solution: Let V and E denote the gravitational potential and…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often conflate gravitational potential with field, assuming $V=0$ forces $E=0$ (or vice‑versa) because they think the zero of potential is unique. Remember $E=-\nabla V$, so a constant (even non‑zero) potential gives $E=0$, and $V$ can be zero at a point while its gradient is non‑zero, yielding $E\neq0$.

Let VV and EE denote the gravitational potential and gravitational field at a point. It is possible to have: (a) V=0V=0 and E=0E=0 (b) V=0V=0 and E≠0E \neq 0 (c) V≠0V \neq 0 and E=0E=0 (d) V≠0V \neq 0 and E≠0E \neq 0

Multiple Choice Options

  • A V=0V=0 and E=0E=0
  • B V=0V=0 and E≠0E \neq 0
  • C V≠0V \neq 0 and E=0E=0
  • D V≠0V \neq 0 and E≠0E \neq 0

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

The correct options are **(a), (b), (c) and (d)**. ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **V=0V=0, E=0E=0** Both can be zero, for example at a point where contributions from a suitable symmetric mass distribution cancel. 2. **V=0V=0, E≠0E\neq0** Potential and field are different physical quantities; a zero value of one does not force the other to vanish. 3. **V≠0V\neq0, E=0E=0** Inside a uniform spherical shell, E=0E=0 while the potential is a nonzero constant:
V=−GMRV=-\frac{GM}{R}
4. **V≠0V\neq0, E≠0E\neq0** This is the ordinary situation at a generic point near a gravitating body. Thus all four combinations are possible.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation