Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 224-225: Q7: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-11 Gravitation P 224-225: Q7 Solution: Let V and E be the gravitational potential and gravitational…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students frequently assume that both gravitational potential $V$ and field $E$ must be continuous across a thin spherical shell, marking statement B as false. In reality $V$ is continuous (the inside constant $-GM/R$ matches the outside $-GM/r$ at $r=R$), while $E$, being the gradient of $V$, jumps by $4pi G\sigma$ (or $GM/R^2$) due to the surface mass density. Remember: a surface mass layer can cause a finite discontinuity in the field even though the potential remains smooth.

Let VV and EE be the gravitational potential and gravitational field at a distance rr from the centre of a uniform spherical shell. Consider the following two statements: (A) The plot of VV against rr is discontinuous. (B) The plot of EE against rr is discontinuous.

Multiple Choice Options

  • A Both A and B are correct.
  • B A is correct but B is wrong.
  • C B is correct but A is wrong.
  • D Both A and B are wrong.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

The correct option is **(c) B is correct but A is wrong**. ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Potential inside a shell** For a uniform spherical shell of radius RR,
V=−GMR(r<R)V=-\frac{GM}{R}\quad(r<R)
so the potential is constant inside. 2. **Continuity of potential** At the surface, the same value is obtained from the outside expression V=−GM/rV=-GM/r. Hence VV is continuous. 3. **Field at the surface** Inside, E=0E=0, whereas just outside the shell,
E=GMR2E=\frac{GM}{R^2}
Thus the field changes discontinuously at the shell. 4. **Conclusion** Hence, **option (c)** is correct.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation