Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 225-227: Q13: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-11 Gravitation P 225-227: Q13 Solution: A solid sphere of mass m and radius r is placed inside a hollow …

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often incorrectly apply the inverse-square law for the hollow shell when the particle is inside it ($x < R$), but the gravitational field inside a uniform spherical shell is exactly zero. Always check the particle's position relative to the shell's radius to determine if the shell contributes to the net force.

A solid sphere of mass mm and radius rr is placed inside a hollow thin spherical shell of mass M and radius R as shown in the following figure. A particle of mass m′m' is placed on the line joining the two centres at a distance xx from the point of contact of the sphere and the shell. Find the magnitude of the resultant gravitational force on this particle due to the sphere and the shell if (a) r<x<2rr < x < 2r, (b) 2r<x<2R2r < x < 2R and (c) x>2Rx > 2R.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** (a) F=Gmm′(x−r)r3F = \frac{Gmm'(x-r)}{r^3} (b) F=Gmm′(x−r)2F = \frac{Gmm'}{(x-r)^2} (c) F=Gmm′(x−r)2+GMm′(x−R)2F = \frac{Gmm'}{(x-r)^2} + \frac{GMm'}{(x-R)^2}. **Step-by-Step Explanation:** **(a)** r<x<2rr < x < 2r: The particle is inside the shell (zero force from shell) and inside the solid sphere's effective mass region. The force is from the sphere only: F=Gmm′(x−r)r3F = \frac{Gmm'(x-r)}{r^3}. **(b)** 2r<x<2R2r < x < 2R: Still inside the shell (zero force). The force is from the sphere: F=Gmm′(x−r)2F = \frac{Gmm'}{(x-r)^2}. **(c)** x>2Rx > 2R: Outside both. Forces add: F=Gmm′(x−r)2+GMm′(x−R)2F = \frac{Gmm'}{(x-r)^2} + \frac{GMm'}{(x-R)^2}.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation