Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 225-227: Q15: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-11 Gravitation P 225-227: Q15 Solution: A thin spherical shell having uniform density is cut in two…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often claim that because a complete thin spherical shell gives zero field at any interior point, the field of each cut half must be equal and opposite at the same point, and then they jump to conclude that the magnitude at A equals that at B without justification. Remember: the zero‑field result applies only to the *whole* shell; for the halves you must apply superposition and reflect the geometry about the cutting plane to relate the field at A from one half to the field at B from the other.

A thin spherical shell having uniform density is cut in two parts by a plane and kept separated as shown in the following figure. The point A is the centre of the plane section of the first part and B is the centre of the plane section of the second part. Show that the gravitational field at A due to the first part is equal in magnitude to the gravitational field at B due to the second part.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** The gravitational field at A due to the first part equals the field at B due to the second part. **Step-by-Step Explanation:** For a complete thin spherical shell, the field at any interior point is zero. At point A (inside the complete shell), the field due to the second part plus the field due to the first part equals zero:
E⃗first(A)+E⃗second(A)=0\vec{E}_{first}(A) + \vec{E}_{second}(A) = 0
By symmetry, the field at A due to the first part equals the field at B due to the second part in magnitude.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation