Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 156-157: Q7: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision P 156-157: Q7 Solution: You are waiting for a train on a railway platform. Your…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students frequently write $m\Delta x_c+M\Delta x_T=0$, mixing displacement with momentum; the correct relation is $m v_c+M v_T=0$ (conservation of horizontal momentum) and only then infer a tiny recoil speed for the trunk. Remember to consider any external horizontal forces (e.g., ground friction) before assuming the system is isolated.

You are waiting for a train on a railway platform. Your three-year-old niece is standing on your iron trunk containing the luggage. Why does the trunk not recoil as she jumps off on the platform?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** **It recoils slightly, but the recoil is usually too small to notice.** ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** **Core Principle** For the child plus trunk, there is essentially no external horizontal force. Hence
mΔxc+MΔxT=0,m\Delta x_c+M\Delta x_T=0,
so
ΔxT=−mMΔxc.\Delta x_T=-\frac{m}{M}\Delta x_c.
**Physical meaning** Since the trunk plus luggage is much heavier than the child, its displacement is very small. **Conclusion** The trunk **does recoil in principle**, but only by a very small amount.

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 156-157: Q1 QP 156-157: Q2 QP 156-157: Q3 QP 156-157: Q4 QP 156-157: Q5 QP 156-157: Q6 QP 156-157: Q7 QP 156-157: Q8 QP 156-157: Q9 QP 156-157: Q10 QP 156-157: Q11 QP 156-157: Q12 QP 156-157: Q13 QP 156-157: Q14 QP 156-157: Q15 QP 156-157: Q16 QP 156-157: Q17 QP 156-157: Q18 QP 156-157: Q19 QP 156-157: Q20 QP 156-157: Q21 QP 156-157: Q22 QP 156-157: Q23 QP 156-157: Q24 QP 156-157: Q25 QP 157-158: Q1 QP 157-158: Q2 QP 157-158: Q3 QP 157-158: Q4 QP 157-158: Q5 QP 157-158: Q6 QP 157-158: Q7 QP 157-158: Q8 QP 157-158: Q9 QP 157-158: Q10 QP 157-158: Q11 QP 157-158: Q12 QP 157-158: Q13 QP 157-158: Q14 QP 157-158: Q15 QP 157-158: Q16 QP 157-158: Q17 QP 157-158: Q18 QP 157-158: Q19 QP 158-159: Q1 QP 158-159: Q2 QP 158-159: Q3 QP 158-159: Q4 QP 158-159: Q5 QP 158-159: Q6 QP 158-159: Q7 QP 158-159: Q8 QP 158-159: Q9 QP 158-159: Q10 QP 158-159: Q11 QP 159-164: Q1 QP 159-164: Q2 QP 159-164: Q3 QP 159-164: Q4 QP 159-164: Q5 QP 159-164: Q6 QP 159-164: Q7 QP 159-164: Q8 QP 159-164: Q9 QP 159-164: Q10 QP 159-164: Q11 QP 159-164: Q12 QP 159-164: Q13 QP 159-164: Q14 QP 159-164: Q15 QP 159-164: Q16 QP 159-164: Q17 QP 159-164: Q18 QP 159-164: Q19 QP 159-164: Q20 QP 159-164: Q21 QP 159-164: Q22 QP 159-164: Q23 QP 159-164: Q24 QP 159-164: Q25 QP 159-164: Q26 QP 159-164: Q27 QP 159-164: Q28 QP 159-164: Q29 QP 159-164: Q30 QP 159-164: Q31 QP 159-164: Q32 QP 159-164: Q33 QP 159-164: Q34 QP 159-164: Q35 QP 159-164: Q36 QP 159-164: Q37 QP 159-164: Q38 QP 159-164: Q39 QP 159-164: Q40 QP 159-164: Q41 QP 159-164: Q42 QP 159-164: Q43 QP 159-164: Q44 QP 159-164: Q45 QP 159-164: Q46 QP 159-164: Q47 QP 159-164: Q48 QP 159-164: Q49 QP 159-164: Q50 QP 159-164: Q51 QP 159-164: Q52 QP 159-164: Q53 QP 159-164: Q54 QP 159-164: Q55 QP 159-164: Q56 QP 159-164: Q57 QP 159-164: Q58 QP 159-164: Q59 QP 159-164: Q60 QP 159-164: Q61 QP 159-164: Q62 QP 159-164: Q63 QP 159-164: Q64

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation