Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session
moderate
QP 156-157: Q10: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision P 156-157: Q10 Solution: Two bodies make an elastic head-on collision on a smooth…
⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls
Students often incorrectly assume that if the collision outcome is unchanged, the standard momentum conservation law ($P_i = P_f$) must also hold in the accelerating frame. You must recognize that pseudo-forces act on the bodies during the collision, making the system's total momentum non-conserved in the non-inertial frame, even though the relative velocity relation remains valid.
Two bodies make an elastic head-on collision on a smooth horizontal table kept in a car. Do you expect a change in the result if the car is accelerated in a horizontal road because of the non inertial character of the frame? Does the equation "Velocity of separation = Velocity of approach" remain valid in an accelerating car? Does the equation "final momentum = initial momentum" remain valid in the accelerating car?
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
**Answer:** **The collision result and relative-speed relation are unchanged, but ordinary momentum conservation is not valid in the accelerating car frame.**
### **Step-by-Step Explanation**
1. **Core Principle**
Both bodies experience the same frame acceleration. Therefore their relative velocity is unaffected.
2. **Elastic collision**
Thus
3. **Momentum**
In the accelerating car frame, pseudo-forces act on the system, so generally in that frame.
4. **Conclusion**
**Collision outcome: unchanged. Separation/approach relation: valid. Momentum conservation in the accelerating frame: not valid.**
All Questions in this Chapter
QP 156-157: Q1
QP 156-157: Q2
QP 156-157: Q3
QP 156-157: Q4
QP 156-157: Q5
QP 156-157: Q6
QP 156-157: Q7
QP 156-157: Q8
QP 156-157: Q9
QP 156-157: Q10
QP 156-157: Q11
QP 156-157: Q12
QP 156-157: Q13
QP 156-157: Q14
QP 156-157: Q15
QP 156-157: Q16
QP 156-157: Q17
QP 156-157: Q18
QP 156-157: Q19
QP 156-157: Q20
QP 156-157: Q21
QP 156-157: Q22
QP 156-157: Q23
QP 156-157: Q24
QP 156-157: Q25
QP 157-158: Q1
QP 157-158: Q2
QP 157-158: Q3
QP 157-158: Q4
QP 157-158: Q5
QP 157-158: Q6
QP 157-158: Q7
QP 157-158: Q8
QP 157-158: Q9
QP 157-158: Q10
QP 157-158: Q11
QP 157-158: Q12
QP 157-158: Q13
QP 157-158: Q14
QP 157-158: Q15
QP 157-158: Q16
QP 157-158: Q17
QP 157-158: Q18
QP 157-158: Q19
QP 158-159: Q1
QP 158-159: Q2
QP 158-159: Q3
QP 158-159: Q4
QP 158-159: Q5
QP 158-159: Q6
QP 158-159: Q7
QP 158-159: Q8
QP 158-159: Q9
QP 158-159: Q10
QP 158-159: Q11
QP 159-164: Q1
QP 159-164: Q2
QP 159-164: Q3
QP 159-164: Q4
QP 159-164: Q5
QP 159-164: Q6
QP 159-164: Q7
QP 159-164: Q8
QP 159-164: Q9
QP 159-164: Q10
QP 159-164: Q11
QP 159-164: Q12
QP 159-164: Q13
QP 159-164: Q14
QP 159-164: Q15
QP 159-164: Q16
QP 159-164: Q17
QP 159-164: Q18
QP 159-164: Q19
QP 159-164: Q20
QP 159-164: Q21
QP 159-164: Q22
QP 159-164: Q23
QP 159-164: Q24
QP 159-164: Q25
QP 159-164: Q26
QP 159-164: Q27
QP 159-164: Q28
QP 159-164: Q29
QP 159-164: Q30
QP 159-164: Q31
QP 159-164: Q32
QP 159-164: Q33
QP 159-164: Q34
QP 159-164: Q35
QP 159-164: Q36
QP 159-164: Q37
QP 159-164: Q38
QP 159-164: Q39
QP 159-164: Q40
QP 159-164: Q41
QP 159-164: Q42
QP 159-164: Q43
QP 159-164: Q44
QP 159-164: Q45
QP 159-164: Q46
QP 159-164: Q47
QP 159-164: Q48
QP 159-164: Q49
QP 159-164: Q50
QP 159-164: Q51
QP 159-164: Q52
QP 159-164: Q53
QP 159-164: Q54
QP 159-164: Q55
QP 159-164: Q56
QP 159-164: Q57
QP 159-164: Q58
QP 159-164: Q59
QP 159-164: Q60
QP 159-164: Q61
QP 159-164: Q62
QP 159-164: Q63
QP 159-164: Q64
Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation
Chapter Practice Bank
Practice all topic-wise questions from Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision
Reference Textbook Solutions
Explore complete chapter exercises for HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1
Competitive PYQ Question Bank
Browse year-wise authentic previous years' questions with solutions
Authentic CBT Mock Tests
Simulate official exam environment with live timer and percentile scoring