Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 156-157: Q4: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision P 156-157: Q4 Solution: The centre of mass is defined as R = 1/M _i m_i r _i . Suppose…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students habitually treat the charge coefficients $q_i$ as positive masses, concluding the “centre of charge’’ must lie inside the convex hull of the charges. In reality $q_i$ can be negative, so the weighted average $\,\vec R_c=\frac{\sum q_i\vec r_i}{\sum q_i}$ may fall outside the line segment (or even be undefined if $\sum q_i=0$). Always check the sign of each charge and the total charge before assuming the centre lies within the geometry of the charge distribution.

The centre of mass is defined as R⃗=1M∑imir⃗i\vec{R} = \frac{1}{M} \sum_i m_i \vec{r}_i. Suppose we define "centre of charge" as R⃗c=1Q∑iqir⃗i\vec{R}_c = \frac{1}{Q} \sum_i q_i \vec{r}_i where qiq_i represents the iith charge placed at r⃗i\vec{r}_i and QQ is the total charge of the system. (a) Can the centre of charge of a two-charge system be outside the line segment joining the charges? (b) If all the charges of a system are in X−YX-Y plane, is it necessary that the centre of charge be in X−YX-Y plane? (c) If all the charges of a system lie in a cube, is it necessary that the centre of charge be in the cube?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** **(a) Yes, for opposite charges; (b) Yes; (c) No, not necessarily.** ### **Step-by-Step Explanation** 1. **Core Principle** The centre of charge is R⃗c=1Q∑qir⃗i\vec R_c=\frac{1}{Q}\sum q_i\vec r_i. Unlike mass, charges can be negative. 2. **Opposite signs** With opposite charges, the coefficients are not positive weights, so the centre of charge can lie outside the segment joining two charges. 3. **Plane and cube** If all charges have zi=0z_i=0, then zc=0z_c=0 (for Q≠0Q\ne0). But in a cube, signed charge weights can place R⃗c\vec R_c outside it. If Q=0Q=0, the definition itself is undefined. 4. **Conclusion** The answers are **yes, yes, no** for (a), (b), and (c).

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 156-157: Q1 QP 156-157: Q2 QP 156-157: Q3 QP 156-157: Q4 QP 156-157: Q5 QP 156-157: Q6 QP 156-157: Q7 QP 156-157: Q8 QP 156-157: Q9 QP 156-157: Q10 QP 156-157: Q11 QP 156-157: Q12 QP 156-157: Q13 QP 156-157: Q14 QP 156-157: Q15 QP 156-157: Q16 QP 156-157: Q17 QP 156-157: Q18 QP 156-157: Q19 QP 156-157: Q20 QP 156-157: Q21 QP 156-157: Q22 QP 156-157: Q23 QP 156-157: Q24 QP 156-157: Q25 QP 157-158: Q1 QP 157-158: Q2 QP 157-158: Q3 QP 157-158: Q4 QP 157-158: Q5 QP 157-158: Q6 QP 157-158: Q7 QP 157-158: Q8 QP 157-158: Q9 QP 157-158: Q10 QP 157-158: Q11 QP 157-158: Q12 QP 157-158: Q13 QP 157-158: Q14 QP 157-158: Q15 QP 157-158: Q16 QP 157-158: Q17 QP 157-158: Q18 QP 157-158: Q19 QP 158-159: Q1 QP 158-159: Q2 QP 158-159: Q3 QP 158-159: Q4 QP 158-159: Q5 QP 158-159: Q6 QP 158-159: Q7 QP 158-159: Q8 QP 158-159: Q9 QP 158-159: Q10 QP 158-159: Q11 QP 159-164: Q1 QP 159-164: Q2 QP 159-164: Q3 QP 159-164: Q4 QP 159-164: Q5 QP 159-164: Q6 QP 159-164: Q7 QP 159-164: Q8 QP 159-164: Q9 QP 159-164: Q10 QP 159-164: Q11 QP 159-164: Q12 QP 159-164: Q13 QP 159-164: Q14 QP 159-164: Q15 QP 159-164: Q16 QP 159-164: Q17 QP 159-164: Q18 QP 159-164: Q19 QP 159-164: Q20 QP 159-164: Q21 QP 159-164: Q22 QP 159-164: Q23 QP 159-164: Q24 QP 159-164: Q25 QP 159-164: Q26 QP 159-164: Q27 QP 159-164: Q28 QP 159-164: Q29 QP 159-164: Q30 QP 159-164: Q31 QP 159-164: Q32 QP 159-164: Q33 QP 159-164: Q34 QP 159-164: Q35 QP 159-164: Q36 QP 159-164: Q37 QP 159-164: Q38 QP 159-164: Q39 QP 159-164: Q40 QP 159-164: Q41 QP 159-164: Q42 QP 159-164: Q43 QP 159-164: Q44 QP 159-164: Q45 QP 159-164: Q46 QP 159-164: Q47 QP 159-164: Q48 QP 159-164: Q49 QP 159-164: Q50 QP 159-164: Q51 QP 159-164: Q52 QP 159-164: Q53 QP 159-164: Q54 QP 159-164: Q55 QP 159-164: Q56 QP 159-164: Q57 QP 159-164: Q58 QP 159-164: Q59 QP 159-164: Q60 QP 159-164: Q61 QP 159-164: Q62 QP 159-164: Q63 QP 159-164: Q64

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation