Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session
moderate
QP 156-157: Q4: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision P 156-157: Q4 Solution: The centre of mass is defined as R = 1/M _i m_i r _i . Suppose…
⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls
Students habitually treat the charge coefficients $q_i$ as positive masses, concluding the “centre of charge’’ must lie inside the convex hull of the charges. In reality $q_i$ can be negative, so the weighted average $\,\vec R_c=\frac{\sum q_i\vec r_i}{\sum q_i}$ may fall outside the line segment (or even be undefined if $\sum q_i=0$). Always check the sign of each charge and the total charge before assuming the centre lies within the geometry of the charge distribution.
The centre of mass is defined as . Suppose we define "centre of charge" as where represents the th charge placed at and is the total charge of the system. (a) Can the centre of charge of a two-charge system be outside the line segment joining the charges? (b) If all the charges of a system are in plane, is it necessary that the centre of charge be in plane? (c) If all the charges of a system lie in a cube, is it necessary that the centre of charge be in the cube?
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
**Answer:** **(a) Yes, for opposite charges; (b) Yes; (c) No, not necessarily.**
### **Step-by-Step Explanation**
1. **Core Principle**
The centre of charge is . Unlike mass, charges can be negative.
2. **Opposite signs**
With opposite charges, the coefficients are not positive weights, so the centre of charge can lie outside the segment joining two charges.
3. **Plane and cube**
If all charges have , then (for ). But in a cube, signed charge weights can place outside it. If , the definition itself is undefined.
4. **Conclusion**
The answers are **yes, yes, no** for (a), (b), and (c).
All Questions in this Chapter
QP 156-157: Q1
QP 156-157: Q2
QP 156-157: Q3
QP 156-157: Q4
QP 156-157: Q5
QP 156-157: Q6
QP 156-157: Q7
QP 156-157: Q8
QP 156-157: Q9
QP 156-157: Q10
QP 156-157: Q11
QP 156-157: Q12
QP 156-157: Q13
QP 156-157: Q14
QP 156-157: Q15
QP 156-157: Q16
QP 156-157: Q17
QP 156-157: Q18
QP 156-157: Q19
QP 156-157: Q20
QP 156-157: Q21
QP 156-157: Q22
QP 156-157: Q23
QP 156-157: Q24
QP 156-157: Q25
QP 157-158: Q1
QP 157-158: Q2
QP 157-158: Q3
QP 157-158: Q4
QP 157-158: Q5
QP 157-158: Q6
QP 157-158: Q7
QP 157-158: Q8
QP 157-158: Q9
QP 157-158: Q10
QP 157-158: Q11
QP 157-158: Q12
QP 157-158: Q13
QP 157-158: Q14
QP 157-158: Q15
QP 157-158: Q16
QP 157-158: Q17
QP 157-158: Q18
QP 157-158: Q19
QP 158-159: Q1
QP 158-159: Q2
QP 158-159: Q3
QP 158-159: Q4
QP 158-159: Q5
QP 158-159: Q6
QP 158-159: Q7
QP 158-159: Q8
QP 158-159: Q9
QP 158-159: Q10
QP 158-159: Q11
QP 159-164: Q1
QP 159-164: Q2
QP 159-164: Q3
QP 159-164: Q4
QP 159-164: Q5
QP 159-164: Q6
QP 159-164: Q7
QP 159-164: Q8
QP 159-164: Q9
QP 159-164: Q10
QP 159-164: Q11
QP 159-164: Q12
QP 159-164: Q13
QP 159-164: Q14
QP 159-164: Q15
QP 159-164: Q16
QP 159-164: Q17
QP 159-164: Q18
QP 159-164: Q19
QP 159-164: Q20
QP 159-164: Q21
QP 159-164: Q22
QP 159-164: Q23
QP 159-164: Q24
QP 159-164: Q25
QP 159-164: Q26
QP 159-164: Q27
QP 159-164: Q28
QP 159-164: Q29
QP 159-164: Q30
QP 159-164: Q31
QP 159-164: Q32
QP 159-164: Q33
QP 159-164: Q34
QP 159-164: Q35
QP 159-164: Q36
QP 159-164: Q37
QP 159-164: Q38
QP 159-164: Q39
QP 159-164: Q40
QP 159-164: Q41
QP 159-164: Q42
QP 159-164: Q43
QP 159-164: Q44
QP 159-164: Q45
QP 159-164: Q46
QP 159-164: Q47
QP 159-164: Q48
QP 159-164: Q49
QP 159-164: Q50
QP 159-164: Q51
QP 159-164: Q52
QP 159-164: Q53
QP 159-164: Q54
QP 159-164: Q55
QP 159-164: Q56
QP 159-164: Q57
QP 159-164: Q58
QP 159-164: Q59
QP 159-164: Q60
QP 159-164: Q61
QP 159-164: Q62
QP 159-164: Q63
QP 159-164: Q64
Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation
Chapter Practice Bank
Practice all topic-wise questions from Chapter-9 Centre of Mass, Linear Momentum, Collision
Reference Textbook Solutions
Explore complete chapter exercises for HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1
Competitive PYQ Question Bank
Browse year-wise authentic previous years' questions with solutions
Authentic CBT Mock Tests
Simulate official exam environment with live timer and percentile scoring