Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 49-50: Q7: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-3 Rest and Motion Kinematics P 49-50: Q7 Solution: A person standing near the edge of the top of a building throws …

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often apply the signed form $v = u + gt$ to compare the two balls, forgetting that $v$ there is a vector; this leads them to think the upward‑thrown ball has a larger final speed because it first climbs. Use the scalar energy relation $v^2 = u^2 + 2gh$ (or conservation of energy) where only $u^2$ appears, ensuring direction does not affect the final speed magnitude.

A person standing near the edge of the top of a building throws two balls A and B. Ball A is thrown vertically upward and B is thrown vertically downward with the same speed. Ball A hits the ground with speed vAv_A and ball B hits the ground with speed vBv_B. We have:

Multiple Choice Options

  • A vA>vBv_A > v_B
  • B vA<vBv_A < v_B
  • C vA=vBv_A = v_B
  • D the relation between vAv_A and vBv_B depends on the height of the building.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

Only statement **(c)** is correct. * **(a) Incorrect** Ball A does not hit the ground with a greater speed. Although it first moves upward, it ultimately falls through a greater vertical distance before reaching the ground. The extra upward motion does not change the final speed relative to the result obtained from energy conservation. * **(b) Incorrect** Ball B does not have a greater final speed either. Both balls have the same mass, the same initial speed magnitude, and start from the same height. * **(c) Correct** Let the building height be hh and the common initial speed be uu. Take the ground as zero potential energy. For ball A,
12mvA2=12mu2+mgh.\frac12mv_A^2=\frac12mu^2+mgh.
For ball B, the same initial kinetic energy and gravitational potential energy are available:
12mvB2=12mu2+mgh.\frac12mv_B^2=\frac12mu^2+mgh.
Therefore,
vA2=vB2.v_A^2=v_B^2.
Since both final speeds are positive magnitudes,
vA=vB.\boxed{v_A=v_B}.
The result is also obtained directly from
v2=u2+2gh.v^2=u^2+2gh.
The initial direction does not appear in this equation; only the square of the initial speed matters. * **(d) Incorrect** The equality does not depend on the building height. For any common initial height, provided air resistance is neglected, both balls reach the ground with equal speed.

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 49-50: Q1 QP 49-50: Q2 QP 49-50: Q3 QP 49-50: Q4 QP 49-50: Q5 QP 49-50: Q6 QP 49-50: Q7 QP 49-50: Q8 QP 49-50: Q9 QP 49-50: Q10 QP 49-50: Q11 QP 49-50: Q12 QP 49-50: Q13 QP 50-51: Q1 QP 50-51: Q2 QP 50-51: Q3 QP 50-51: Q4 QP 50-51: Q5 QP 50-51: Q6 QP 50-51: Q7 QP 50-51: Q8 QP 50-51: Q9 QP 50-51: Q10 QP 51-54: Q1 QP 51-54: Q2 QP 51-54: Q3.1 QP 51-54: Q3.2 QP 51-54: Q3.3 QP 51-54: Q3.4 QP 51-54: Q4.1 QP 51-54: Q4.2 QP 51-54: Q5 QP 51-54: Q6 QP 51-54: Q7 QP 51-54: Q8.1 QP 51-54: Q8.2 QP 51-54: Q8.3 QP 51-54: Q9.1 QP 51-54: Q9.2 QP 51-54: Q10 QP 51-54: Q11 QP 51-54: Q12 QP 51-54: Q13 QP 51-54: Q14 QP 51-54: Q15.1 QP 51-54: Q15.2 QP 51-54: Q15.3 QP 51-54: Q16 QP 51-54: Q17 QP 51-54: Q18.1 QP 51-54: Q18.2 QP 51-54: Q19 QP 51-54: Q20 QP 51-54: Q21 QP 51-54: Q22 QP 51-54: Q23.1 QP 51-54: Q23.2 QP 51-54: Q23.3 QP 51-54: Q24 QP 51-54: Q25.1 QP 51-54: Q25.2 QP 51-54: Q25.3 QP 51-54: Q26 QP 51-54: Q27 QP 51-54: Q28 QP 51-54: Q29 QP 51-54: Q30 QP 51-54: Q31 QP 51-54: Q32.1 QP 51-54: Q32.2 QP 51-54: Q32.3 QP 51-54: Q33.1 QP 51-54: Q33.2 QP 51-54: Q34 QP 51-54: Q35 QP 51-54: Q36 QP 51-54: Q37 QP 51-54: Q38 QP 51-54: Q39 QP 51-54: Q40 QP 51-54: Q41 QP 51-54: Q42 QP 51-54: Q43.1 QP 51-54: Q43.2 QP 51-54: Q44 QP 51-54: Q45 QP 51-54: Q46.1 QP 51-54: Q46.2 QP 51-54: Q47.1 QP 51-54: Q47.2 QP 51-54: Q48 QP 51-54: Q49.1 QP 51-54: Q49.2 QP 51-54: Q50 QP 51-54: Q51 QP 51-54: Q52 QPage 48-49: Q1 QPage 48-49: Q2 QPage 48-49: Q3 QPage 48-49: Q4 QPage 48-49: Q5 QPage 48-49: Q6 QPage 48-49: Q7 QPage 48-49: Q8 QPage 48-49: Q9 QPage 48-49: Q10.1 QPage 48-49: Q10.2 QPage 48-49: Q10.3 QPage 48-49: Q11 QPage 48-49: Q12 QPage 48-49: Q13 QPage 48-49: Q14

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation