Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 49-50: Q12: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-3 Rest and Motion Kinematics P 49-50: Q12 Solution: A river is flowing from west to east at 5 m/min . A man on the…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often confuse minimizing crossing time with minimizing path length, incorrectly trying to cancel the river's drift by swimming upstream. To minimize time, the swimmer must maximize the velocity component perpendicular to the bank, which requires swimming directly across (due north), regardless of the river's flow.

A river is flowing from west to east at 5 m/min5 \text{ m/min}. A man on the south bank, capable of swimming at 10 m/min10 \text{ m/min} in still water, wants to swim across in the shortest time. He should swim:

Multiple Choice Options

  • A due north
  • B 30� east of north
  • C 30� north of west
  • D 60� east of north.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

Only statement **(a)** is correct. * **(a) Correct** The man wants to cross the river in the shortest possible time. His swimming speed relative to still water is 10 m/min10\ \text{m/min}. If he swims at an angle θ\theta with the north direction, the component of his swimming velocity across the river is
v⊥=10cos⁡θ.v_\perp=10\cos\theta.
This component is maximum when
θ=0∘.\theta=0^\circ.
Thus, he should swim due north, giving the maximum northward velocity of 10 m/min10\ \text{m/min}. The crossing time is then minimum. * **(b) Incorrect** If he swims 30∘30^\circ east of north, the northward component becomes
10cos⁡30∘=53 m/min,10\cos30^\circ=5\sqrt3\ \text{m/min},
which is less than 10 m/min10\ \text{m/min}. Hence the crossing time increases. * **(c) Incorrect** Swimming 30∘30^\circ north of west gives a northward component
10sin⁡30∘=5 m/min,10\sin30^\circ=5\ \text{m/min},
which is not maximum. * **(d) Incorrect** For 60∘60^\circ east of north, the northward component is
10cos⁡60∘=5 m/min,10\cos60^\circ=5\ \text{m/min},
again giving a longer crossing time. The river velocity of 5 m/min5\ \text{m/min} towards east changes the point where the man reaches the opposite bank, but it does not change the condition for minimum crossing time.

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 49-50: Q1 QP 49-50: Q2 QP 49-50: Q3 QP 49-50: Q4 QP 49-50: Q5 QP 49-50: Q6 QP 49-50: Q7 QP 49-50: Q8 QP 49-50: Q9 QP 49-50: Q10 QP 49-50: Q11 QP 49-50: Q12 QP 49-50: Q13 QP 50-51: Q1 QP 50-51: Q2 QP 50-51: Q3 QP 50-51: Q4 QP 50-51: Q5 QP 50-51: Q6 QP 50-51: Q7 QP 50-51: Q8 QP 50-51: Q9 QP 50-51: Q10 QP 51-54: Q1 QP 51-54: Q2 QP 51-54: Q3.1 QP 51-54: Q3.2 QP 51-54: Q3.3 QP 51-54: Q3.4 QP 51-54: Q4.1 QP 51-54: Q4.2 QP 51-54: Q5 QP 51-54: Q6 QP 51-54: Q7 QP 51-54: Q8.1 QP 51-54: Q8.2 QP 51-54: Q8.3 QP 51-54: Q9.1 QP 51-54: Q9.2 QP 51-54: Q10 QP 51-54: Q11 QP 51-54: Q12 QP 51-54: Q13 QP 51-54: Q14 QP 51-54: Q15.1 QP 51-54: Q15.2 QP 51-54: Q15.3 QP 51-54: Q16 QP 51-54: Q17 QP 51-54: Q18.1 QP 51-54: Q18.2 QP 51-54: Q19 QP 51-54: Q20 QP 51-54: Q21 QP 51-54: Q22 QP 51-54: Q23.1 QP 51-54: Q23.2 QP 51-54: Q23.3 QP 51-54: Q24 QP 51-54: Q25.1 QP 51-54: Q25.2 QP 51-54: Q25.3 QP 51-54: Q26 QP 51-54: Q27 QP 51-54: Q28 QP 51-54: Q29 QP 51-54: Q30 QP 51-54: Q31 QP 51-54: Q32.1 QP 51-54: Q32.2 QP 51-54: Q32.3 QP 51-54: Q33.1 QP 51-54: Q33.2 QP 51-54: Q34 QP 51-54: Q35 QP 51-54: Q36 QP 51-54: Q37 QP 51-54: Q38 QP 51-54: Q39 QP 51-54: Q40 QP 51-54: Q41 QP 51-54: Q42 QP 51-54: Q43.1 QP 51-54: Q43.2 QP 51-54: Q44 QP 51-54: Q45 QP 51-54: Q46.1 QP 51-54: Q46.2 QP 51-54: Q47.1 QP 51-54: Q47.2 QP 51-54: Q48 QP 51-54: Q49.1 QP 51-54: Q49.2 QP 51-54: Q50 QP 51-54: Q51 QP 51-54: Q52 QPage 48-49: Q1 QPage 48-49: Q2 QPage 48-49: Q3 QPage 48-49: Q4 QPage 48-49: Q5 QPage 48-49: Q6 QPage 48-49: Q7 QPage 48-49: Q8 QPage 48-49: Q9 QPage 48-49: Q10.1 QPage 48-49: Q10.2 QPage 48-49: Q10.3 QPage 48-49: Q11 QPage 48-49: Q12 QPage 48-49: Q13 QPage 48-49: Q14

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation