Q1.17: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Introduction to physics 1.17 Solution: Question 17: The frequency of vibration of a string depends on…
Students often treat the length L as directly proportional (positive exponent) instead of inversely proportional, overlooking that L appears in the denominator after solving the dimensional equations. Remember to write the dimensional balance $[T^{-1}] = [L]^a[MLT^{-2}]^b[ML^{-1}]^c$ and solve for $a$, which yields $a=-1$, giving $f\propto L^{-1}$, not $L^{+1}$.
Question 17: The frequency of vibration of a string depends on the length L between the nodes, the tension F in the string, and its mass per unit length m. Guess the expression for its frequency from dimensional analysis.
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
Solution:
Let the frequency f be related to L, F, and m as follows:
f = kLᵃFᵇmᶜ ...(1)
where k is a dimensionless constant.
Dimensions:
- f (frequency) = [T⁻¹] or [M⁰L⁰T⁻¹]
- L (length) = [L]
- F (force) = [MLT⁻²]
- m (mass per unit length) = [ML⁻¹]
Substituting the dimensions into equation (1):
[M⁰L⁰T⁻¹] = [L]ᵃ[MLT⁻²]ᵇ[ML⁻¹]ᶜ
[M⁰L⁰T⁻¹] = [M^(b+c)L^(a+b-c)T^(-2b)]
Equating the powers of M, L, and T:
- For M: 0 = b + c
- For L: 0 = a + b - c
- For T: -1 = -2b
Solving these equations:
- From the third equation: b = 1/2
- Substituting b = 1/2 into the first equation: c = -1/2
- Substituting b = 1/2 and c = -1/2 into the second equation: a = -1
Therefore, a = -1, b = 1/2, and c = -1/2. Substituting these values into equation (1):
f = kL⁻¹F^(1/2)m^(-1/2)
f = k(√(F/m))/L
Thus, the frequency is given by:
f = (k/L)√(F/m)