Q1.16: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Introduction to physics 1.16 Solution: Question 16: Let I = current through a conductor, R = its…
Students frequently assume that dimensional analysis alone can prove Ohm's law and set the dimensionless constant k to 1, overlooking that the method only yields the proportional form $V\propto IR$ and cannot determine the actual numerical factor or guarantee linearity without experimental evidence.
Question 16: Let I = current through a conductor, R = its resistance, and V = potential difference across its ends. According to Ohm's law, the product of two of these quantities equals the third. Obtain Ohm's law from dimensional analysis. Dimensional formulae for R and V are [ML²I⁻²T⁻³] and [ML²T⁻³I⁻¹] respectively.
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
Solution:
Let the relationship between V, I, and R be represented as:
V = kIᵃRᵇ ...(1)
where 'k' is a dimensionless constant.
Given dimensions:
- V = [ML²T⁻³I⁻¹]
- I = [I]
- R = [ML²I⁻²T⁻³]
Substituting these dimensions in equation (1):
[ML²T⁻³I⁻¹] = [I]ᵃ[ML²I⁻²T⁻³]ᵇ
[ML²T⁻³I⁻¹] = [MᵇL²ᵇT⁻³ᵇI^(a-2b)]
Comparing the powers of M, L, T, and I on both sides:
- For M: 1 = b
- For L: 2 = 2b
- For T: -3 = -3b
- For I: -1 = a - 2b
From the first three equations, we get b = 1. Substituting b = 1 in the fourth equation:
-1 = a - 2(1) -1 = a - 2 a = 1
Therefore, a = 1 and b = 1. Substituting these values in equation (1):
V = kI¹R¹ V = kIR
Since k is a dimensionless constant, we can assume k = 1. Thus, we get Ohm's law:
V = IR