Q1.15: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Introduction to physics 1.15 Solution: Question 15: Theory of relativity reveals that mass can be…
Students often conclude from dimensional analysis that the proportionality constant $k$ must be 1, writing $E=mc^2$ directly; however, dimensional analysis can only fix the powers of $m$ and $c$, not the numerical factor. Emphasize that $k$ is undetermined by dimensions and must be obtained from theory or experiment.
Question 15: Theory of relativity reveals that mass can be converted into energy. The energy E so obtained is proportional to certain powers of mass m and the speed c of light. Guess a relation among the quantities using the method of dimensions.
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
Solution:
Let the relationship between energy (E), mass (m), and the speed of light (c) be:
E ∝ mᵃcᵇ
or E = kmᵃcᵇ ……(1)
where k is a constant of proportionality.
Dimensions:
- E (energy) = [ML²T⁻²]
- m (mass) = [M]
- c (speed of light) = [LT⁻¹]
Substituting the dimensions into equation (1):
[ML²T⁻²] = [M]ᵃ[LT⁻¹]ᵇ
[ML²T⁻²] = [MᵃLᵇT⁻ᵇ]
Comparing the powers of M, L, and T:
- a = 1
- b = 2
- -2 = -b => b = 2
Therefore, the required relation is:
E = kmc²
Since k is a dimensionless constant, we often write it as 1, leading to the well-known equation:
E = mc²