Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 441: Q2: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-20 Dispersion and Spectra P 441: Q2 Solution: Can the dispersive power = _v - _r/µ - 1 be negative? What is…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

In the formula $omega= rac{mu_v-mu_r}{mu-1}$, $mu$ is the refractive index of the prism material relative to the surrounding medium. For a hollow prism in water, $mu=n_{ ext{air}}/n_{ ext{water}}<1$, so $mu-1$ is negative. Students often assume $mu>1$ and ignore this, giving a positive $omega$ incorrectly. Always compute $mu$ relative to the medium first and check the sign of $mu-1$ before evaluating $omega$.

Can the dispersive power ω=μv−μrμ−1\omega = \frac{\mu_v - \mu_r}{\mu - 1} be negative? What is the sign of ω\omega if a hollow prism is immersed into water?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** No, the dispersive power ω=μv−μrμ−1\omega = \frac{\mu_v - \mu_r}{\mu - 1} cannot be negative for an ordinary material prism in air. However, the sign of ω\omega can become negative if a hollow prism is immersed in water. **Step-by-Step Explanation:** 1. **Definition of dispersive power** For a thin prism, the dispersive power is defined as
ω=μv−μrμy−1,\omega=\frac{\mu_v-\mu_r}{\mu_y-1},
where μv\mu_v, μr\mu_r, and μy\mu_y are the refractive indices for violet, red, and yellow light respectively. 2. **Why ω\omega is positive for ordinary materials** For all ordinary transparent materials such as glass, quartz, water, etc., the refractive index is larger for shorter wavelengths. Hence
μv>μr.\mu_v>\mu_r.
Also, for a material in air,
μy−1>0.\mu_y-1>0.
Therefore
ω=μv−μrμy−1>0.\omega=\frac{\mu_v-\mu_r}{\mu_y-1}>0.
So dispersive power is positive for normal prisms. 3. **Can ω\omega be negative?** Yes, it can be negative in a special case: when a **hollow prism** is immersed in water and the hollow space is filled with air. In that situation, the "prism material" is air, and the surrounding medium is water. The relevant refractive index is the **relative refractive index of air with respect to water**:
μrel=μairμwater.\mu_{\text{rel}}=\frac{\mu_{\text{air}}}{\mu_{\text{water}}}.
Since μair<μwater\mu_{\text{air}}<\mu_{\text{water}}, we have
μrel<1.\mu_{\text{rel}}<1.
For air, the dispersion is extremely small and, in the visible range, the variation of refractive index with wavelength is opposite in the relative sense: μv<μr\mu_v<\mu_r effectively for the relative index. Hence
μv−μr<0,\mu_v-\mu_r<0,
while μy−1<0\mu_y-1<0 as well because μy<1\mu_y<1. Their ratio can therefore be negative. 4. **Conclusion** - For a normal solid or liquid prism in air: ω>0\omega>0. - For a hollow prism immersed in water: ω\omega can be negative.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation