Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 441: Q1: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-20 Dispersion and Spectra P 441: Q1 Solution: The equation = _v - _r/µ - 1 was derived for a prism having…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often insert a large prism angle, a slab, or a sphere into the thin‑prism dispersion formula $\omega=\frac{\mu_v-\mu_r}{\mu-1}$, forgetting that the derivation assumes $A\ll1$ (so $\sin A\approx A$) and a linear deviation $\delta\approx A(\mu-1)$. For large $A$ or different geometries the higher‑order terms and geometry change, so the expression no longer holds.

The equation ω=μv−μrμ−1\omega = \frac{\mu_v - \mu_r}{\mu - 1} was derived for a prism having small refracting angle. Is it also valid for a prism of large refracting angle? Is it also valid for a glass slab or a glass sphere?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** No, it is not valid for a prism of large refracting angle. No, it is not valid for a glass slab or sphere. **Step-by-Step Explanation (Verified):** The equation ω=μv−μrμ−1\omega = \frac{\mu_v - \mu_r}{\mu - 1} was derived for a **thin prism** with a small refracting angle AA. For a large refracting angle, the deviation is not simply A(μ−1)A(\mu - 1), so the formula breaks down. For a **glass slab**, there is no deviation of the mean ray (only lateral shift), and no angular dispersion on emergence. For a **glass sphere**, the geometry is completely different and this formula does not apply [citation:4].

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation