Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 271-272: Q4: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-13 Fluid Mechanics P 271-272: Q4 Solution: Equal mass of three liquids are kept in three identical…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often incorrectly assume that the liquid with the highest density exerts the maximum force because it has the greatest weight per unit volume, neglecting that its height is inversely proportional to density. In a cylindrical vessel, the force on the base is always equal to the total weight of the liquid ($mg$), regardless of density, because the hydrostatic pressure term $\rho gh$ simplifies to $mg/A$ when $h = m/(\rho A)$.

Equal mass of three liquids are kept in three identical cylindrical vessels A, B and C. The densities are ρA\rho_A, ρB\rho_B, ρC\rho_C with ρA<ρB<ρC\rho_A < \rho_B < \rho_C. The force on the base will be

Multiple Choice Options

  • A maximum in vessel A
  • B maximum in vessel B
  • C maximum in vessel C
  • D equal in all the vessels

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** (c) maximum in vessel C. **Explanation:** For equal masses, volume V=m/ρV = m/\rho. The liquid with highest density ρC\rho_C has the smallest volume, hence smallest height h=V/Ah = V/A in the same base area. Force on base =ρghA=ρg(m/(ρA))A=mg= \rho g h A = \rho g (m/(\rho A)) A = mg. Wait�force on base depends on pressure at base, which is ρgh\rho g h. Since h=m/(ρA)h = m/(\rho A), pressure =ρg⋅m/(ρA)=mg/A= \rho g \cdot m/(\rho A) = mg/A, independent of density! The force on the base is the same for all three.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation