Q1.5: Question Bank - Physics Class 11 Units & Measurement 1.5 Solution: The pair of physical quantities not having the same dimensions…
Students frequently confuse surface tension’s unit (N m⁻¹) with energy per area and write its dimension as $[ML^{-1}T^{-2}]$, or they treat impulse as a force and give it $[MLT^{-2}]$; the correct dimensions are $[MT^{-2}]$ for surface tension (force per length) and $[MLT^{-1}]$ for impulse (force × time, i.e., change in momentum). Remember to derive each quantity from its fundamental definition before comparing dimensions.
The pair of physical quantities not having the same dimensions is:
Multiple Choice Options
- A Pressure and Young's modulus
- B Torque and energy
- C Surface tension and impulse
- D Angular momentum and Planck's constant
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
To determine which pair does not have the same dimensions, let's analyze the dimensional formula for each physical quantity.
1. Dimensional Analysis of the Pairs
A. Pressure and Young's Modulus
- Pressure ():
- Young's Modulus (): . Since strain is dimensionless and stress is Force/Area:
- Result: These have the same dimensions.
B. Torque and Energy
- Torque ():
- Energy (): Capacity to do work () =
- Result: These have the same dimensions.
C. Surface Tension and Impulse
- Surface Tension ():
- Impulse ():
- Result: These do not have the same dimensions.
D. Angular Momentum and Planck's Constant
- Angular Momentum ():
- Planck's Constant ():
- Result: These have the same dimensions.
Final Answer
The correct option is C. Surface tension and impulse have distinct physical natures and different dimensional formulas.
Summary Table:
Quantity | Dimensional Formula |
Surface Tension | |
Impulse |