Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 380: Q6: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-17 Light Waves P 380: Q6 Solution: Three observers A, B and C measure the speed of light coming…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often treat the speed of light as invariant ($c$) for all observers, even in a material medium, and ignore that in water the light’s phase velocity is $c/n$ relative to the water. When an observer moves relative to the medium, the measured speed changes (classical addition/subtraction or Fresnel drag), not the frequency. Remember to separate the medium‑fixed light speed from observer‑dependent measurements and apply the appropriate velocity‑addition rule.

Three observers A, B and C measure the speed of light coming from a source to be νA\nu_A, νB\nu_B and νC\nu_C. A moves towards the source and C moves away from the source at the same speed. B remains stationary. The surrounding space is water everywhere.

Multiple Choice Options

  • A νA>νB>νC\nu_A > \nu_B > \nu_C
  • B νA<νB<νC\nu_A < \nu_B < \nu_C
  • C νA=νB=νC\nu_A = \nu_B = \nu_C
  • D νB=12(νA+νC)\nu_B = \frac{1}{2}(\nu_A + \nu_C)

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** (a) nuA>nuB>nuC\\nu_A > \\nu_B > \\nu_C. **Explanation:** In water, the speed of light is c/muc/\\mu relative to the medium. Observer A moving towards the source measures a higher speed, and C moving away measures a lower speed. Hence nuA>nuB>nuC\\nu_A > \\nu_B > \\nu_C.

All Questions in this Chapter

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation