Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 250-251: Q1: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Chapter-12 Simple Harmonics Motion P 250-251: Q1 Solution: A student says that he had applied a force F = -k√(x) on a…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

Students often treat the coefficient $k$ in $F=-k\sqrt{x}$ as a tunable function of $x$ to force a linear $F\propto x$ relationship, but SHM requires a *constant* restoring coefficient $K$ so that $F=-Kx$ for all $x$. If the force depends on $\sqrt{x}$, the motion cannot be simple harmonic regardless of how $k$ varies.

A student says that he had applied a force F=−kxF = -k\sqrt{x} on a particle and the particle moved in simple harmonic motion. He refuses to tell whether kk is a constant or not. Assume that he was worked only with positive xx and no other force acted on the particle.

Multiple Choice Options

  • A As xx increases kk increases.
  • B As xx increases kk decreases.
  • C As xx increases kk remains constant.
  • D The motion cannot be simple harmonic.

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** (b) As xx increases kk decreases; (d) The motion cannot be simple harmonic. **Explanation:** For SHM, the force must be of the form F=−KxF = -Kx where KK is a constant. Here F=−kxF = -k\sqrt{x}. Comparing: Kx=kx⇒k=KxKx = k\sqrt{x} \Rightarrow k = K\sqrt{x}. Since KK is constant, as xx increases, kk increases. But for SHM, the force must be proportional to xx, not x\sqrt{x}. So the motion **cannot** be simple harmonic.

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 249-250: Q1 QP 249-250: Q2 QP 249-250: Q3 QP 249-250: Q4 QP 249-250: Q5 QP 249-250: Q6 QP 249-250: Q7 QP 249-250: Q8 QP 249-250: Q9 QP 249-250: Q10 QP 249-250: Q11 QP 249-250: Q12 QP 249-250: Q13 QP 249-250: Q14 QP 249-250: Q15 QP 249-250: Q16 QP 250-251: Q1 QP 250-251: Q2 QP 250-251: Q3 QP 250-251: Q4 QP 250-251: Q5 QP 250-251: Q6 QP 250-251: Q7 QP 250-251: Q8 QP 250-251: Q9 QP 250-251: Q10 QP 250-251: Q11 QP 250-251: Q12 QP 250-251: Q13 QP 250-251: Q14 QP 250-251: Q15 QP 250-251: Q16 QP 250-251: Q17 QP 250-251: Q18 QP 250-251: Q19 QP 250-251: Q20 QP 250-251: Q21 QP 251-252: Q1 QP 251-252: Q2 QP 251-252: Q3 QP 251-252: Q4 QP 251-252: Q5 QP 251-252: Q6 QP 251-252: Q7 QP 251-252: Q8 QP 251-252: Q9 QP 251-252: Q10 QP 251-252: Q11 QP 251-252: Q12 QP 251-252: Q13 QP 251-252: Q14 QP 251-252: Q15 QP 251-252: Q16 QP 252-256: Q1 QP 252-256: Q2 QP 252-256: Q3 QP 252-256: Q4 QP 252-256: Q5 QP 252-256: Q6 QP 252-256: Q7 QP 252-256: Q8 QP 252-256: Q9 QP 252-256: Q10 QP 252-256: Q11 QP 252-256: Q12 QP 252-256: Q13 QP 252-256: Q14 QP 252-256: Q15 QP 252-256: Q16 QP 252-256: Q17 QP 252-256: Q18 QP 252-256: Q19 QP 252-256: Q20 QP 252-256: Q21 QP 252-256: Q22 QP 252-256: Q23 QP 252-256: Q24 QP 252-256: Q25 QP 252-256: Q26 QP 252-256: Q27 QP 252-256: Q28 QP 252-256: Q29 QP 252-256: Q30 QP 252-256: Q31 QP 252-256: Q32 QP 252-256: Q33 QP 252-256: Q34 QP 252-256: Q35 QP 252-256: Q36 QP 252-256: Q37 QP 252-256: Q38 QP 252-256: Q39 QP 252-256: Q40 QP 252-256: Q41 QP 252-256: Q42 QP 252-256: Q43 QP 252-256: Q44 QP 252-256: Q45 QP 252-256: Q46 QP 252-256: Q47 QP 252-256: Q48 QP 252-256: Q49 QP 252-256: Q50 QP 252-256: Q51 QP 252-256: Q52 QP 252-256: Q53 QP 252-256: Q54 QP 252-256: Q55 QP 252-256: Q56 QP 252-256: Q57 QP 252-256: Q58

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation