Verified Solution • 2025–26 Session moderate

QP 192: Q21: HC Verma: Concepts of Physics - Volume 1 Rotational Mechanics P 192: Q21 Solution: A hollow sphere, a solid sphere, a disc and a ring all having…

⚠️ Common Exam Traps & Conceptual Pitfalls

In the rolling‑acceleration formula $a= rac{gsin heta}{1+I/(mR^2)}$, a larger $I/(mR^2)$ actually *decreases* $a$. Students often invert this relationship and think a heavier or more spread‑out body will roll faster. Always check the denominator: the smallest $I/(mR^2)$ gives the largest acceleration and thus the shortest time.

A hollow sphere, a solid sphere, a disc and a ring all having same mass and radius are rolled down on an inclined plane. If no slipping takes place, which one will take the smallest time to cover a given length?

Step-by-Step Verified Solution

**Answer:** The solid sphere will take the smallest time to cover the given length. **Step-by-Step Explanation:** For a body rolling without slipping down an incline of angle θ\theta, the linear acceleration is:
a=gsin⁡θ1+ImR2a = \frac{g\sin\theta}{1 + \frac{I}{mR^2}}
The body with the smallest moment of inertia ratio ImR2\frac{I}{mR^2} has the largest acceleration and therefore takes the least time. - Solid sphere: ImR2=25=0.4\frac{I}{mR^2} = \frac{2}{5} = 0.4 - Disc: ImR2=12=0.5\frac{I}{mR^2} = \frac{1}{2} = 0.5 - Hollow sphere: ImR2=23≈0.67\frac{I}{mR^2} = \frac{2}{3} \approx 0.67 - Ring: ImR2=1\frac{I}{mR^2} = 1 Since the solid sphere has the smallest ratio, it has the largest acceleration and takes the smallest time.

All Questions in this Chapter

QP 192: Q1 QP 192: Q2 QP 192: Q3 QP 192: Q4 QP 192: Q5 QP 192: Q6 QP 192: Q7 QP 192: Q8 QP 192: Q9 QP 192: Q10 QP 192: Q11 QP 192: Q12 QP 192: Q13 QP 192: Q14 QP 192: Q15 QP 192: Q16 QP 192: Q17 QP 192: Q18 QP 192: Q19 QP 192: Q20 QP 192: Q21 QP 192: Q22 QP 193-194: Q1 QP 193-194: Q2 QP 193-194: Q3 QP 193-194: Q4 QP 193-194: Q5 QP 193-194: Q6 QP 193-194: Q7 QP 193-194: Q8 QP 193-194: Q9 QP 193-194: Q10 QP 193-194: Q11 QP 193-194: Q12 QP 193-194: Q13 QP 193-194: Q14 QP 193-194: Q15 QP 193-194: Q16 QP 193-194: Q17 QP 193-194: Q18 QP 193-194: Q19 QP 193-194: Q20 QP 193-194: Q21 QP 193-194: Q22 QP 193-194: Q23 QP 193-194: Q24 QP 193-194: Q25 QP 193-194: Q26 QP 194-195: Q1 QP 194-195: Q2 QP 194-195: Q3 QP 194-195: Q4 QP 194-195: Q5 QP 194-195: Q6 QP 194-195: Q7 QP 194-195: Q8 QP 194-195: Q9 QP 194-195: Q10 QP 194-195: Q11 QP 194-195: Q12 QP 194-195: Q13 QP 194-195: Q14 QP 194-195: Q15 QP 195-200: Q1 QP 195-200: Q2 QP 195-200: Q3 QP 195-200: Q4 QP 195-200: Q5 QP 195-200: Q6.1 QP 195-200: Q6.2 QP 195-200: Q7 QP 195-200: Q8 QP 195-200: Q9.1 QP 195-200: Q9.2 QP 195-200: Q10 QP 195-200: Q11 QP 195-200: Q12 QP 195-200: Q13 QP 195-200: Q14 QP 195-200: Q15 QP 195-200: Q16 QP 195-200: Q17 QP 195-200: Q18 QP 195-200: Q19 QP 195-200: Q20 QP 195-200: Q21 QP 195-200: Q22 QP 195-200: Q23 QP 195-200: Q24 QP 195-200: Q25 QP 195-200: Q26 QP 195-200: Q27 QP 195-200: Q28 QP 195-200: Q29 QP 195-200: Q30 QP 195-200: Q31 QP 195-200: Q32 QP 195-200: Q33 QP 195-200: Q34 QP 195-200: Q35 QP 195-200: Q36 QP 195-200: Q37 QP 195-200: Q38 QP 195-200: Q39 QP 195-200: Q40 QP 195-200: Q41 QP 195-200: Q42 QP 195-200: Q43 QP 195-200: Q44 QP 195-200: Q45 QP 195-200: Q46 QP 195-200: Q47 QP 195-200: Q48 QP 195-200: Q49 QP 195-200: Q50 QP 195-200: Q51 QP 195-200: Q52 QP 195-200: Q53 QP 195-200: Q54 QP 195-200: Q55 QP 195-200: Q56 QP 195-200: Q57 QP 195-200: Q58 QP 195-200: Q59 QP 195-200: Q60 QP 195-200: Q61 QP 195-200: Q62 QP 195-200: Q63 QP 195-200: Q64 QP 195-200: Q65 QP 195-200: Q66 QP 195-200: Q67 QP 195-200: Q68 QP 195-200: Q69 QP 195-200: Q70 QP 195-200: Q71 QP 195-200: Q72 QP 195-200: Q73 QP 195-200: Q74 QP 195-200: Q75 QP 195-200: Q76 QP 195-200: Q77 QP 195-200: Q78 QP 195-200: Q79 QP 195-200: Q80 QP 195-200: Q81 QP 195-200: Q82 QP 195-200: Q83 QP 195-200: Q84 QP 195-200: Q85 QP 195-200: Q86

Related Learning Resources & Exam Preparation