A mischievous monkey throws a small, heavy fruit vertically upwards from the top of a cliff of… — Distance and Displacement
A mischievous monkey throws a small, heavy fruit vertically upwards from the top of a cliff of height H with an initial velocity v0. At the exact same instant, a second monkey, positioned at the bottom of the cliff, throws an identical fruit vertically upwards with an initial velocity 2v0.
Assuming no air resistance and a constant acceleration due to gravity g, determine the condition on v0 and H such that the two fruits collide at a height greater than 3H/4 above the bottom of the cliff.
Step-by-Step Verified Solution
Let's set up the problem carefully.
---
## Step 1: Define coordinates
Let the bottom of the cliff be and upward be positive.
- **Fruit 1** (thrown from top of cliff, height ):
- **Fruit 2** (thrown from bottom, ):
---
## Step 2: Collision condition
They collide when :
The terms cancel:
---
## Step 3: Height at collision
Substitute into (or ):
---
## Step 4: Apply the condition y_{\text{collision}} > \frac{3H}{4}
Since H > 0, divide through by :
---
## Step 5: Additional physical constraint
For the fruits to actually collide **above the cliff bottom and while both are in flight**, we also need:
- The collision time t = H/v_0 > 0 (always true).
- Fruit 2 must not have already fallen back to the ground before collision. Its time of flight is . We need t < T_2:
- Fruit 1 must not have hit the ground before collision. It starts at height and we need y_1(t) > 0 at collision. Since y_{\text{collision}} > 3H/4 > 0, this is automatically satisfied.
Compare the two conditions:
Since \frac{2}{5} = 0.4 > \frac{1}{4} = 0.25, the stronger condition is:
This automatically ensures v_0^2 > gH/4.
---
## Final Answer
Equivalently:
Under this condition, the two fruits collide at a height greater than above the bottom of the cliff.